Catcha Falling Star - Sagittarius or Libra?

Coming back for ten days in July, original plan was 5 days on the beach somewhere (Travellers Groupon?) and 5 days at Catcha in either Sagittarius or Libra. Well, that didn't go as planned because in the day it took to talk about it with my wife, someone else beat us to some of the 5 days in both rooms. So, we decided to start our trip at with 5 days at Catcha instead... and of course, by the next day, someone had booked nights in those rooms too.

So, as soon as I saw that I called them and grabbed the days in the middle so we have 4 nights in Sagittarius and 3 in Pisces.

As of right now, Libra is also available for the same 4 nights we are in Sagittarius. Any reason to switch to Libra?

Is it worth spending the extra $50 a night to move to Gemini over Pisces?

Thanks for the advice!

Libra for sure...stayed there twice...quieter over there

I'll second Libra for the quietness.

I stayed in Sagi and loved it! Would definitely stay there again.

What makes the location of Sagittarius louder than Libra? Is it closer to the bar? I don't remember that much noise from the restaurant at night. From the pictures I thought you'd have more privacy in Sagittarius.

We stayed in Moon a few nights last year, and didn't find it noisy at all. Any idea how that will compare?

Yes close to the bar & on that side your exposed to Rick's Cafe noise & Banana Shout...Libra is next to private property & a security wall very quite & private!

We stayed in Sagi in March of last year and any noise from Ricks or the restaurant, which I don't recall being bothersome, was over by early evening maybe 9:00 or 10:00, from what I recall. Nights were peaceful IMO and the only noise I remember was the sound of the waves against the cliffs which I love. Great to sleep to. We kind of liked hearing the music from Ricks in the early evening & watching the action from a distance.

I'd take Pisces over Gemini. Gemini is side by side (twins!)
Pisces stands alone. It is close to the parking lot. But, an adorable little place with an outdoor shower that you access thru your bathroom & your own deck with a water view.

Check out Negrilonestop for some different pics & video than Catcha's website.

http://negrilonestop.com/catchafallingstar_photos.shtml