Looking for best secluded cabin on the cliffs, any ideas?

Rounhouse at Citronella. Cottage 1 or 3 at Xtabi. Citronella is very private

I would take a long look at Westender Inn. They have cabins in back that aren't advertised but are fully equipped and very affordable.

One thing you should know about is that just past the Lighthouse the water/currents gets really rough. Since you mention staying at Citronella, you know the deal on certain days when the current is rough. I also have stayed at Ocean Edge (ocean side) for many years when Citronella was booked solid around Christmas time, then would move into Citronella around the second week in January when the place emptied out.

Sea Grape is 3 different houses to rent with full kitchens etc. AC in the bedrooms. Juicey is good cook and will prepare meals in the little cook shack on site and deliver to your veranda at your request. 2 of the villas are on the water and teh bigger one is set back a bit. 2 of them share a sea access and 1 is totally secluded and private. Only one staffer onsight. Little store directly across the street so you can be as private as you want to be. They will ring a bell before walking down the path to the villa

I would also suggest Westender that place looks real special and seem very private

Have stayed at westender a few times, quiet and nice. To bad the priests that come every year are there my weeks. Often wondered what they think of the many free porn channels they have up there!!

Think I will pass on sea grape. Too many people hanging around the street there.

Enjoying Home Sweet Home very much. Great views easy water access good vibes. We find it easy to eat and stock up supplies, by foot or taxi. Kinda in the middle LTU or Canoe pick a direction and lots of good choices Cheers!