I've never been a big rum lover, mostly from having not spent enough time in the Caribbean. The rum I had in Negril was by far better than anything I had before. The Xtabi dirty banana with Appleton rum and the overproof down the straw and on top was the best ever. The Dragon Spitfire beer with rum in it was also very nice. Rum in the islands is quite a local specialty and preference. I hope you find that perfect rum and mixer!