Xtabi or Rockhouse?

Finally narrowed it down to these? Which one would you suggest?

Kimmy - I haven't been to either, but I recently had my eye on Rockhouse for our 10 year anniversary.
Unfortunately it was all booked for the days we wanted.

I received a lot of great information from everyone about that hotel in this thread here:

http://negril.com/forum/showthread.p...ight=Rockhouse

Hope that helps you make your decision:)

This one is easy for me kimmy, Xtabi. Xtabi, Xtabi, Xtabi!! :)

ha ha Clarity!!

lol Giurigay!
:D
Also you might want to look at Catcha Falling Star or Tensing Pen for your honeymoon. Both are very romantic resorts.

What are you looking to spend per night?

Yes....Clarity is right, that changes my answer

If you want a recommendation for where I would pick...Catcha Falling Star, definitely.
Tensing Pen would be my runner up!

Haven't stayed at Rock House, though I have been on the property many times. Stayed in cottage #4 at Xtabi twice.

I like Xtabi and especially #4. However, I prefer the area around Rock House. Think the water is prettier and the area nicer. Just my opinion.

Kimmy - For me this is easy, but I've been thinking and you and I have had a little back and forth on this. It seems that for you it's been evaluating Rockhouse against a number of properties. If it's in your budget it seems that it's really in your heart already. I don't think you'll be disappointed, it is gorgeous.

Oooooooh...Get that Premium Villa!!! That thing looks BAD! I wanna see someone's pictures of it so if you stay there please post some :)

I would go with the Rockhouse, we have stayed there I think 4 times, got kicked up a night in the premium villa one night for free, I wish I took more pics, I cant imagine why I didnt, but it was awesome.Attachment 11942Attachment 11942

sorry I posted the same pic twice, the pic thing is confusing

It depends on the room type....If you do Xtabi you should do the ocf round cottages,but the ocf villas at the Rockhouse are VERY pricey.....