Just my humble opinion:

Current beer prices at my local tavern for a can of PBR or Narragansett are around $3 USD per can. Any national brand ( Bud, Miller or Coors) $6USD. Craft beer starts at $7USD and upwards.

Paying $5USD for an ice cold red stripe at Tony's Hut is okay with me.
You can't beat the view! Certainly a better view than my local tavern.
Tony is a great guy and I have spent a few memorable afternoons hanging at his bar chatting with him about the runnings in Negril!

Respect,

VVHT aka Happy