Haven't tried too many (yet). Angela's (above BarBBarn) used to be my favorite.....until I went across the street to the Sunrise Club and it was amazing (also pastas, etc.).....then tried Ciao Jamaica and it was SUPER good (like you Walleye I tried Jerk Ckn and others and they were DELISH).
I have heard Sea Star Cocobread Pizza is good, Bella Donna and is it Itialian Cafe on the beach road? So I guess I only have a favorite for a minute til I try the next one (lol)