My husband and I are planning to stay in the Port Antonio area for the first week in March 2017 It'll be our first time visiting this area and I am having a lot of trouble deciding where to stay. We'll be in Negril the week prior, then taking the Knutsford to PA. This will be our 5th trip to Jamaica, the land we love

Has anyone stayed at Coconut Isle Villa on Long Bay? I love the fact that it's ON the beach. It does look a bit run down, but we don't need luxury. As long as it's clean, has a refrigerator, private bathroom and balcony or veranda with beautiful views we are happy. We would rent the entire house, which is a bit more $ than we planned to spend per night. But if someone says that it's a great place to stay, we are OK with spending extra to be on the beach.

We are also considering Fairy Hill Palms, Caribbean Dawn and Pimento Lodge. We prefer to be close walking distance to route taxis, which I believe all of these options are.

Any recommendations? Thanks for all your help!