Nothing wrong with Tilapia for sure.
Anyone ever had the Goggle-eye fish.
Little fishes with great big bulging eyes.
They are harvested only during a certain time in either Jan or Feb and I remember seeing several small fishing boats with nets in an ever decreasing circle, 'trapping' them in the cove across from Sexy Rexy's.
Seems they are a local treat as they were being sold all along the west end by the bucketful after the harvesting . Rexy had a fire going near the road and was cooking them and a crowd of people were there to get their taste.
While staying at Seastar the goggle-eye were being prepared for a special staff meal and we managed to score a plateful. They were steamed and served with pieces of lime and were quite delicious. (we didn't eat the eyes though).