We have stayed at Seastar Inn over the last 10 years or so, beginning when there were only 6 rooms to rent.
All of the rooms are great in their own way.
Linda and I loved room 8 the last two times. It's away from the bar/restaurant/pool noise. (although most nights it's not noisy at all)
It's near the clothes line; which you can use to dry a few things when it's not in use for sheets etc.
The property is totally beautiful in front of that room and it has two queen beds, fridge (all rooms have a fridge), mini kitchen and Seastar's island made furniture.
Not to mention the multi channel cable t.v. and air conditioning.
Not having to climb stairs is a plus after leaning on the bar all night, and you can get room service of course at no extra charge.
Just use the cell phone provided with the room to call the bar/restaurant.
I also like room 1, although it doesn't have a mini kitchen. It does have a fridge and a great view out the front gate to observe the comings and goings and such.
Room 4..one of the upper rooms next to the office area is also cosy and has a great balcony.
All of the rooms have their own charm; even the least expensive, smaller rooms are fine.
It think we stayed in 14 or 15 facing the backside of the other rooms.
The annex building at one time housed the beach police patrol before it was refurbished by Seastar.
You just can't go wrong with any of the rooms.