XTABI vs SAMSARA (non-AI)

[Ohio_Buckeye_1]

Just a little contrary opinion. I don't think food/drink differences matters very much since you are going non-AI, as I do. Now, if you were asking between two AI's, then my answer would be different.

I've never based my decision on the food at the hotel because there are so many places to try - I end up rarely eating at the hotel. Similar with drinks, but when relaxing by the pool or beach I do want a constant supply of something to drink. But even there, I'm the kind of traveler who buys a cooler and picks up beer, rum, and mixers from the Chinaman Shop to keep a good supply in the room and save on the drinks by the pool.

All said - most of my eating and drinking is done elsewhere than the hotel. Just something you should ask yourself.

I would suggest you base decision on the room amenities and price and also on the vibe of the staff.
I've stayed at Legends and shuttled to Samsara, and would stay there. I have not visited Xtabi so can't offer opinion for there.