Outside of tourist areas=no tip. It might be a hard concept to grasp unless you have spent a bunch of time in areas that don't have people leaving around extra money around like they don't need it. Lol, after trying to tip the change on beer a few times and being treated like I'm trying to "make it rain".......just pay and smile and repeat business if needed.

Inside tourist areas=nothing if the service sucks. No 10% because of this or that.....give me good service and I'll push a little extra your way.

At hotels/motels/cottages....I don't use housekeeping....rather I refuse it....so no direct tip for housekeeping. Indirectly= left over food items, beer, rum, kids toys, school supplies, and on and on.....

If I want to toss my hard earned money toward people that might need it more than me I'll continue to donate supplies and money to the soup kitchen (and other places in need) who can spread that money for several to enjoy instead of just to some random person who provided less than par service because they were lucky enough to get a wait staff job in Negril.