We go to Dr. Art, maybe 100 yards north of Rooms on the Beach. He's just a few steps north of those three or four tables selling trinkets; the ones that really hound you when you walk by. No matter what time of the day it is, it's always "please, you're my first sale."
He's in a little shed that is set back about 20 feet. He's a younger kid, maybe 22. The reason I stopped there in the first place was because I saw actually him sitting next to a pile of his tools and wood chips in the sand, working on pieces. I' like to see things being crafted becuase I feel like most stuff is made in china. Small pieces are around $10-$15 usd, medium runs $20-$40. There was one large piece, a stool about 24" high, with an eagle catching a fish carved inside of it. That he quoted at $100 but came down to $80. We didn't get it becuase of the hassle of lugging it back.

He'll do custom stuff for you too. He says to bring a picture or sketch and give him a few days. I haven't dont his yet but maybe next time.

Other than him, Mason is the guy with the huge carvings on the beach with the sign that says "take a picture and support the artist" or somethign like that. Between boat bar and Nirvana. He's got nice work and is a chill rasta dude, not a pusher or hustler. Prices were reasonable at first quote. I didn't bother haggling becuase nothign spoke to me the day I was there. I'll be going back though.