The Mrs. and I never had the $ for a BIG vacation, our vacations were usually camping in a tent somewhere. I don't even remember why we chose Jamaica the 1st time but it was probably around 1996 that we went to Sandals in Ocho Rios and we had a great time but that property had a terrible beach that was more coral than sand and it had a fence running into the ocean at each of the resort so no one could walk the beach.
After that we heard about Negril's alleged great beach that one could walk for miles without fences so a few years later when w could afford to return we booked Negril and have now been back 10 more times. We did take a break one year to return after Katrina to NOLA where we were married but otherwise when friends ask why Negril we always reply "If it ain't broke - don't fix it!"