Hussyband, I just picked some random flight days in November for US Air (flight 860) and they are non stop coming and going for about $540 Round Trip. You don't get into MBJ until 1:50 PM. But the departing flight doesn't leave till 3 PM so you get most of your last day on the island. We are waiting for a better price or we might not be going this year.
Regards,
Bob