Toby Inn is the first place that comes to mind. I have paid $50 to $80 per night at Tobys.There are beautiful beaches down the street that charge about $5 a day for entrance-Doctor's Cave Beach which is not affiliated with the hotel of the same name and Cornwall Beach. When you add the $70 to the cost of food and beverage you might come out almost even if you shop for a good rate at Royal Decameron Montego Bay. Another choice would be Sunset Beach Resort. You can find some real good rates out of Canada for instance including airfare. Avoid the Gloriana Hotel at all costs. I do not recommend Doctors Cave or Gloucester Hotel either. Protect your valuables wherever you are. I would not stay at any of the so called B&Bs. You will be away from the beach and really at the mercy of the landowner. Don't spend your vacation trying to find food and transportation from a sketchy area.