Never stayed in Pisces but we love the cliffs and Catcha a lot!!!! This last trip we only stayed on the beach and although I love the beach there is a different feeling that hits you when on the cliffs. We went up to Ivan's one night for dinner and got so homesick for Catcha. It is a beautiful property and in my opinion you can't go wrong. The staff is wonderful, wonderful, wonderful and Ivan's is one of the best restaurants in Negril IMHO so you can't go wrong there. And although walking on the road is challenging, it's easy to get around the cliffs, and lots of little shops and restaurants there as well. The one thing about Catcha that you should be aware of, as any place on the cliffs, is the water can get too rough to swim in which is a challenge for those of us who love to be in the water. However, you can arrange to spend the day on the beach and a cheap, short taxi ride away you are there. Enjoy Catcha!!!