We have been to Seastar many times for cocktails and the Sat show but have not stayed there. We have stayed at Catcha Gardens a few times and we love it
there. Staff is great and I love that it is so quiet, That's how we usually like to start a trip. And Catcha has Belle and Pumpkin whom I have grown to love, they move in with us when we are there. I think both places are awesome. I think Seastar is better if your looking to mingle, Catcha if you just want to relax and unwind. Both times at Catcha I felt we had the whole place to ourselves, and I LOVE their pool.