Back for another installment of "help choose my adventure..."

I'm booking a kindof last minute trip for the end of Sept. Original plan was to stay at Firefly for 8 nights but thought that might be too long to stay put so I've decided to stay three nights on the cliffs. Narrowed it down to Catcha Gardens and Seastar. I know many here are attached to one or the other. Both Catcha and Seastar look wonderful and seem to have their own perks. I already have a trip booked to BCC and Treehouse for Thanksgiving but couldn't wait!

What to do?