Been there, done that! We were bringing 5 couples down to The Pineapple in October 2 years ago. Heard that they were closing. They transferred us up to Beaches. I was very leery of doing the big AI but we had a ball there, (except for all of the kids). There was a lot of food choices and the service was great. We even talked Lindley into moving us into a beach side room. I will always book The Pineapple over Beaches but what the hell, a $5000.00 vacation for half price (or more). It worked for us.
