The Gloriana is a creepy dive! You will be lucky to not be robbed there! I would never stay at the Gloucester, Doctor's Cave or the Caribic. El Greco is at top of the hill, inconvenient and tacky. Tobys is a better option if you pay $50 to $75. If you can get a good rate at Royal de Cameron, I would choose it above all the rest. Use it as a base and tour and dine out. You can have pizza delivered even. I would try to pay no more than about $180 per couple. When you figure in some meals and drinks even if you go elsewhere some, you will still be okay. Watch your valuables where ever you stay. I love Jamaica and Jamaicans , but they will steal whatever is not nailed down. Thirty five years on the island.