Have not heard good things regarding the value at Beachcomber. Considering your statement above, don't go AI at Legends, unless the price is comparable to other accommodation only deals. You would want to budget for meals off resort. There are so many great little bars, happy hours and reasonably priced good food walking distance to hotels. Sitting on the beach, vendors will walk by selling patties, jerk pork, fruit, juices, breads...no need for mediocre AI food. Take a collapsible cooler from your room fridge to your beach chair, and cold beer at many beach bars for the equivalent of $2-$3.