Traveller's is significantly far away from CoCo..I guess it depends what you guys are looking for...Coco is a bit far down for my taste as I prefer to be by Bourbon and the night scene....I wouldn't say it's too rustic...or any more so than a lot of other places...Coco just added new rooms....I tend to stay more for preferred location on the beach than the accommodation....so personally, I'd go with Traveller's...