I just tried Grand Pineapple in January. I would stay again if the price was right, but my preference is non AI. The biggest plus is location. Easy walking distance to Shamrock, Time Square for ATM, Drifters Bar for their awesome jam sessions and Yellow Bird for their delicious and cheap drink specials. And everything else on Long Bay! I stayed in a beachside cottage which was a disappointment compared to non AI rooms I've stayed in, small with basically one window (mine viewed the manor building) and little natural light. Food was ok to good, although def missing out if you don't also go out and enjoy made to order meals or roadside jerk such as Best in the West. Cocktails were AI quality (no comparison to Yellow Bird or the rum punch at Drifters).