That's a hard call but if only one then I would pick Drifters by far!(we have been to all, Half Moon before they had they had Calico Jacks tho)

The vibe at Drifters is by far my favourite. It is a fun mix of visitors and locals performing and the bar owner Luddy makes everyone feel like a long lost friend. You can beat the bucket of red strips deal they have either(I would love to tell you the exact price but those afternoons are a little hazy