Our fav is Eddies De Bar. Very similar to 3 dives but Eddie doesn't have the crowds like his brother so he can get it right every time.
Biggas in Green Island was the first jerk we had on the island. I'm not sure if we got a bad one or what but it was dry dry dry. I wouldn't go out of my way for it.
Tony's is good but I need to make sure to tell him no ketchup otherwise it comes covered with it.
Best in the West is really good.
Bourbon Beach also has a different but very good sauce they serve with their chicken. The chicken itself is average but I can't get enough of that sauce.