Great suggestion - go where the locals go.
Also great suggestions by Captain Oil. We do 1-5, 7-8. White Sands is our go to hotel as it is budget friendly.
Thanks for all of the quick responses! To summarize, here are the restaurants everyone mentioned so far (by price point, not already on OneStop):
$
Jeans (on Firestation Road)
Juici Patties
Mango Tree Restaurant
Reggae Man
Sips and Bites
Sweet Spot
$$
Alfred's on the Beach
Home Sweet Home Restaurant
Jamaican-Style Restaurant & Bar
Sweet Spice
$$$
Charela
Uncategorized
Keney's Chinese Restaurant
Montanas
Swordfish Grill