Yes we return the same night. We usually leave Ochi around 6PM and get back to Negril around 9PM. Hiring a driver for an all day trip with a family of 5 will probably start in the $300US range and that would be cheap, by my guess it would likely be more. Probably better to rent a car and drive. While I agree with Island Girl about the challenge of driving in Jamaica, the trip from Negril to Ochi is about as easy as it gets. Even I could do it :-)