i dont believe there is such a thing as a rental in jamaica without a 1200 OR 1500$us deposit.
correct my thinking about this deposit thing if i am incorrect..
Island has a plan that requires only a $250ish deposit. It's an extra $25 a day, but you have zero liability in case of an accident. Unless of course you've been drinking or anything like that...all bets are off with any rental company if that's the case.