I think you will enjoy Treasure Beach - Dubloon looks really nice! We have been renting a villa near Billys Bay for the last few years. We always stop in Black River and stock up - water, beer, rum, wine, snacks - we let the villa cook do the bulk of the food stuff, but anything else we want we usually pick up. Especially the drinks - the cook will have to take a route taxi to Black River to purchase your food and then haul everything back. I feel it is easier if we have a driver and room to load up the trunk or back of van with the heavier stuff. I cannot remember if they have Titos there or not - I am thinking they do, but cannot say for sure. You may be able to pick it up at the airport?

Happy Birthday and have a great time!