Haven't been to my favourite hotel in Negril since January 2010; but; Seastar Inn has fabulous food.
I'm talking outside of their great buffet.
Their cooked to order meals are nothing short of fantastic and they will go out of their way to accomodate their guests tastes.
The chicken is top notch; done on a rotisserie system similar to the "Swiss Chalet" style in Canada.
Google Swiss Chalet if you're interested.
The pan fried snapped is wonderful.
The soup is always nice.
Coco Bread Pizza is a marvel.
Room service available, no extra charge.