We stayed at Travellers last year and were quite pleased. Pros: clean, safe, consistent, huge pool set back from beach (was great on a few days when it was very windy), nice staff, location (close to town). Cons: Bar/restaurant wasn't the best and was overpriced, location (close to town = at the very west end of the beach, so a long hike to many places)

We found ourselves eating breakfast and some other meals at Kuyaba. great place to hang and dine. I'd stay there if I could get under $100, but didn't really see the rooms. I think some of them are quite rustic. Maybe not as nice as Travellers?