If you have a larger group or feel like splurging, the Buccaneer is an awesome property. http://treasurebeach.com/
Outdoor shower, huge rooftop with shade, nice little pool. Suzie cooked breakfast and some dinners for us while we were there or you can go it alone. Great driver too that will take you around. Very quiet beach a short walk down the hill.

The best part is you can see the fishermen returning from their day - walk down there and grab the freshest fish and lobsters - bring them up and fill your belly!

Tough drive from Negril but really beautiful. TimAir also flies to Treasure Beach if you really want to splurge.