For future trips to Little Ochie, you can rent a guide and car, you can rent a boat and Captain, and you can stand along the road and flag down a route taxi heading east and go to Junction where you can get a route taxi going to Alligator Pond. You want to do the last suggestion leaving around 11 am. The drop-off spot is less than a block from the restaurant, just walk towards the sea. There should be a route taxi going to Treasure Beach when you're done with lunch. If not, just do the reverse i.e. take a route taxi to Junction and then one to TB. Later in the day, route taxi's to TB become a bit more infrequent. Each method has their plus and minuses but the route taxi is very, very easy and by far the least expensive, less than $500J ($125J to Junction, $155J to Alligator Pond) each way as of February 2016. Be aware the route taxi men work hard for their money and tipping is not a city in China. Also if you are in a hurry to return and don't want to wait until the taxi is full, if you are the first in the taxi, ask him how much he needs to leave asap.