Hey Moose,

We did the daytime two years ago. We have done the evening one twice now and the daytime once. I would recommend the evening over the daytime, you get 3 stops, one to snorkle, one to swim caves and one at Ricks. The evening one is always a party with the RS/RUM flowing as soon as you board. The daytime one was really mellow, it was cool to see Bobby Cay and the lobster was good but I would just take a small fishing boat over and do same thing for less money since no one is really partying anyways. FWIW they ask $120 for the evening for a couple we settled at $80J and tipped $10. They really tried hard for US at that price, but J was all I had w me.