I'd rather cut the tour short than sleep over. I'm already paying for my room in Negril!

I guess if I had to choose, I'd pick YS falls and pelican bar, and save Appleton for another trip. It's going to be a long day as it is, and we'd have to leave Negril around 8:30 am just to fit it all in before sunset.

Good tip about captain Dennis, chuck! I just came across his info, hadn't looked into him further.