Forum Content Discussion

[Carrie]

That was an excellent cleaning job of said argument. I'm thinking my esteemed fellow member appreciates same.

As I look through a similar thread, it does drift off to frustrations regarding censorship, real/bad information, misinterpretations of comments … yada yada blah blah.

I think it may be appropriate to air thoughts, frustrations and be heard. This is only my second forum in life and I'm pretty much ready to take my bat and go home. Here are my thoughts:

. Yes it is a site for tourists and I certainly understand the responsibility to keep things accurate. This is a hard one, as I do not think local papers get it right. The process is slow; welcome to Jamaica. I don't have a problem with missing information, facts not quite true. It is the nature of the beast all around the world. I understand the forum feels responsible to be true, but as a tourist site, exercise caution with censorship as we all know that with any crime, it takes time to have the authorities gather information and release. Reader be aware and wary that it is all very new news.

. I noted a few comments that forum users felt chastised, again censored … I sure feel a little bit of that spice too. The forum is meant to help fellow tourists … from learned tourists that care to take the time and share. Do we not all sift through information at hand and make our own informed decisions. I do not believe this type of forum can exist and be vibrant without sharing all types of information. Certain advice and contributions are quite different for certain travellers. Canada and United States for instance.

. My personal experience with the forum as a newbie has been hit and miss. I do find a harsh tone, inability to state little things that are intended to be light, but taken all wrong and out of context. Welcome to an international audience. It feels heavy here when all profess peace and love.

. The moderators are really great. I give my admiration for your time and diplomacy. You come across as informed and light and welcoming.

. Last comment is that it takes all to have camaraderie . I feel that "some" of those with long history on the board feel ownership. Of course, that is good and bad. I really would have hoped more fostering of new contributors that will enjoy sharing as you all have.

That said … feel free to delete my truth. Peace love and all that jazz. Carrie

[Papa Georgie]

Carrie,

Relax an Repeat after me...
Negril is a paradise...
Negril is a paradise...
Negril is a paradise...
Negril is a paradise...
Negril is a paradise...

Got it?

[wrtiii]

Carrie, Internet forums in general are private. This is Rob's place. Things posted here are not public or protected free speech, they are things being posted on Rob's site. As such, Rob certainly has the right to set the terms of use and to limit discussion to things he deems both appropriate and civil, just as he would if we were visitors in his own house. I think this is made quite clear in the forum guidelines and FAQ. I know many people use the word "censorship" to mean "you won't let me post what I want on your Web site." However, that's a misuse of the term. Anyone is free to set up their own Web site with whatever rules they want. Censorship would mean not allowing you to do that.

Any of us may believe that what we have to say is really important for others to hear. That doesn't mean Rob has to agree with us, or supply us with an audience.

While I too have seen things posted that I considered harsh, I also know that people have a tendency to read a completely unintended "tone" into a message. My own writing style tends to be quite blunt, and I have several times had people take offense to a message that I thought was a simple statement of fact posted in response to a question.

I find this forum to contain vast useful information, and in general to be extremely well-moderated to keep everything friendly and on track. In the forum guidelines, it makes clear that this is not intended to be a Jamaica news site, and offers suggestions as to where to go for news. The news sites have their own comment sections for discussion of the latest events. This is not the only site I check when I'm planning for Jamaica; different sites have their own focus.

[Carrie]

Thank you and I sure hope I did not come across as not appreciative of all the efforts. Or lacking respect. Kudos to all. My background is marketing and communications and perceptions are all mighty. I just mention that there did not appear a place to air frustrations and they appeared willy nilly in other threads by members … that is all I offer. I very much admire Rob and all those that give their time and effort and support and fun to have such a community of camaraderie and much needed assistance to fellow tourists. Warmth and a huge thank you to all.

[JDd]

cheers

[Ras Walleye]

Same as it's been since the beginning. Rob's board, Rob's rules. As it is a business he has a responsibility to his sponsors as well as the members. They are what pays for our ability to come here and share our love of Negril.

[Carrie]

Amen.

[johng]

Carrie from Vancouver, some very interesting comments!!! Something about Canadian thinking that sometimes makes sense.

I don't know anybody on this forum personally and have not visited Negril for several years but I must say I enjoy the positive vibes (most often), great photos, points of views and ideas put forth.

Negril and Jamaica are very dear to me and I have visited many times over a long period of time. The Negril.com forum allows me to relive and revisit a wonderful place from my past which often times gets me through a tough day. Let's face it the world has changed drastically and in many ways not for the better.

Rob and bnewb have done a nice job trying to keep many people happy which is always an impossibility. What is proper for a forum??? Who knows but I am happy to escape here when old happy memories are desirable over the current and sometimes scary reality of today.

In conclusion to all of you who participate and try and make life better and happier for us all through their contributions, Thank You!!!!

[Carrie]

I thank you for the gentle honest feedback. No need for the speakeasy. Wisdom and joy of the history experienced here and to all sharing valid gospel now and in the future.

[jomack]

Not sure exactly what this post is about... but I got to say I like that Rob takes great length to ensure we have the correct information as possible. I fell in love with Negril over a year ago, but got married in Ocho Rios and been to JA 6 times so far. This board was the beginning to our trip for 10 days in Negril and the information read here from all the boardies (personal preferences, experiences etc) assisted me with my choices, or gave me insight.

Sure glad this forum is not on facebook, because it would be a joke, and misleading information, or some very strong view points that may not be necessary..

Keep up the good work, I do not post a lot, but read this site everyday while working ! Wishing I was in Negril.

I love reading the stories, the funnies, and everything in between
Cheers !