Reach Falls is great for swimmers and non-swimmers, there were guys hanging around but really no need for a guide even. That hole you describe is a little unnerving but you don't have to do that to enjoy yourself.

SammyB has the area dialed in - but my $2.5J:

Eat or hang at CliffHangers on the way to or from Reach - please post something if you do, they were building a guest house last Dec and I would love to stay there if all is irie. The food was great and the bar/restaurant/guest house location is unbelievable.

Woody's is good for some cheap eats and hanging out.

Don' t miss eating at Soldier Camp, call to make sure he's open - if not, he may open up for you! He did for us, then an hour later the place was rocking!

GeeJam has great food and drinks but is pricey - old school Mento band Jolly Boys plays there every Wed I think. We stayed there and for once, I think someplace that expensive was worth it - maybe we can afford it again in the future... If you eat there, make sure you walk the property, lush and amazing.