Marley, Banana Shout doesn't come near Catcha, thats for sure. I personally did not like Banana Shout but I know others love it there. I was sooooo hot in the cottage that I was miserable there. Those walls built on the sides of Banana Shout seem to keep any breeze away. I was there in December too. We also lost power for most of my time there, which I know is not their fault, so of course no ceiling fan. Uggghh! We hung out out Seastar all day. Even my Jamaican friends thought it was super hot there and I've never heard them complain about heat!!