Irine
If you find yourself in Bloody Bay, there's a guy at the beginning of the vendors booths with a trap full of lobster in the surf. The same goes if you get yourself out to Booby Cay
As for New Orleans, Acme is the most run down, beat up, delicious place to eat in my opinion. They couldn't shuck the oysters or bring the crawfish fast enough. Unfortunately we haven't been there lately, since for a few dollars more we can be in Negril