From Couples Negril to Fun Holiday, sounds like you've run the gamut from high-end to budget friendly. For something different, check out Sea Grape Villas. It's like having your own private cottage with a cook and housekeeping. The Wild Grape villa even has it's own private section of cliffs with water access. The one downside is no pool - but you can always use the pool next door at Negril Escape or take a walk to Sea Star and sit in their swim-up bar.