Restaurants - Sad list that are now closed. :( Looking for replacements.

[Craig123]

Pilots cafe was extremely horrible the last 2 reaches and we use to go there all the time.
Our new favorite place is in the cliffs past the lighthouse called Murphy's. Very good eats especially the pumpkin rice. We make it all the time.

JamaicaLance/Mary -
What's the atmosphere like at Murphy's and are they an evening place? Is it cliff side or inland? Large or small place? Should I call ahead or just show up.

[JamaicanCurrys]

JamaicaLance/Mary -
What's the atmosphere like at Murphy's and are they an evening place? Is it cliff side or inland? Large or small place? Should I call ahead or just show up.

The restaurant is inland Medium size spot Best to make reservations. One of the nicest restaurants in Jamaica.

[Bnewb]

The restaurant is inland Medium size spot Best to make reservations. One of the nicest restaurants in Jamaica.

L&M...while I respect you thinking Murphy's as "one of the nicest restaurants in Jamaica"...I would like to add the word rustic.
When I think of something as being the "nicest" I think of a place similar to Terra Nova etc in Kingston or even Rockhouse's atmosphere in Negril.
It's all about the outfit I may wear that night!

[Mike_D]

L&M...while I respect you thinking Murphy's as "one of the nicest restaurants in Jamaica"...I would like to add the word rustic.

I would agree with Bnewb. In my mind, the vibe at Murphy's isn't much different than Erica's or Quality's Seabreeze. I think Murphy's had some hammocks on the side porch, which is cool.

I'm probably in the minority here, but I thought Murphy's food was good - but not outstanding. I know he gets rave reviews on TA, but there are a number of other small, local restaurants that I would rank higher.

[JamaicanCurrys]

L&M...while I respect you thinking Murphy's as "one of the nicest restaurants in Jamaica"...I would like to add the word rustic.
When I think of something as being the "nicest" I think of a place similar to Terra Nova etc in Kingston or even Rockhouse's atmosphere in Negril.
It's all about the outfit I may wear that night!

Corrected. It is a bit rustic but what we look for is the quality of food we receive with the presentation they give for under $6000 J with drinks in most cases. Being a chef by trade we are not easy to please. There food is made with Love and the freshest ingredients in my opinion. We ate there three nights in a row last season which is a first for us. My wife does dress up anywhere we eat in the evenings LOL

Respect

[heater]

We loved Murphy’s. Very quaint place and the seafood was fresh and delicious.