Tell me your choice.

[Bnewb]

Oohhh, tough one...I'm also curious to hear if there's someone that's stayed at all four properties in recent years.
I've actually stayed at two of the properties...but that feels like a hundred years ago and it was only two of the properties.

[Captain Oil]

CCLP .............. dead center of the beach - easy walk either way to end of the beach, consistently has lots of beach depth when other places have it come and go, perfectly tapered sand into the ocean and beyond into deeper water, lots of beach frontage so you can find a area all to yourselves, plenty of quality beach chairs for everyone, beautiful well kept grounds, two pools if you are not a salt water ocean person, nice beach front grill with bar, quality restaurant for more formal meals, another bar for afternoons and evening cocktails, great modern rooms where everything works, quality and friendly management, servers, bartenders, maintenance works, cleaning persons, etc..... CCLP has been our go to place on the beach for 20+ years. We have looked at them all and for the price, IMHO nothing beats CCLP