Farmer,
We actually did the Booby Cay trip last year. We arranged it with Captain Raymond so he picked us up at Travellers along with some other people. Stopped at the pier to pick up some cold Red Stripe along with some teasing of Famous Vincent who was also there and then hit the reef for some snorkeling. Ok, I didn't snorkel since I don't swim. I know, I know....how can that be when you're from the land of 10,000 lakes and frogponds?! (Long story)
Anyway, don't knock staying on the boat and doing shots of overproof with the mate!!
Afterwards, we landed the SS Minnow at Booby Cay and Raymond cooked up some wicked lobster and chicken for those we didn't want seafood. We hung out on the island and did some exploring since the rest of the island is pretty thick with trees and brush.
We were there for a couple of hours and it was a great time. (Just hide your eyes when you go by Hedo and the naked kayakers!)