We've been 9 times & usually have gone in Nov. since that is our anniversary but have gone in Dec. Feb. & April also. We love the sea temp in Nov. it's very warm & it's not real crowded yet & the prices are good BUT you go home & have the long cold winter ahead of you. Not so good. Dec. was nice but the same thing with going home. We went twice in Feb. & it was so nice going home to spring on it's way & getting out of the bitter cold for a while but the water temp. was not as warm in Feb. & took some getting used to. But then it's still the Caribbean water, it's not like trying to get used to the Pacific Ocean at anytime (cold). We went once in mid April after the costs went down & we found the water to be much like in Nov. It was warm. We thought April was fine except the only thing we didn't like was no lobster