Actually, if you stay at the Grand Pineapple for a week in Jan, it'll cost you $2200 to stay in their beach side cottage with all the food and drink you want for 2 adults. Coco will charge you $1700 for just their deluxe room (equivalent in amenities to the GP cottage) and Charella will charge you $1800 for just their deluxe room. So GP seems to be the better deal when you consider that 2 adults will easily spend $1000-$1500 in food and drink for a week (depending on their preferred dining experiences and 'party level'). Only if the people staying at GP are big wanderers, day and night for food and drink, would GP be a bad deal (which doesn't seem the case with the group that Vince is describing).