We've tried AI and NI, but it surely depends upon how much you want to spend. When going to non-inclusive hotels, we tend to spend quite a bit of money. We don't just stay at our hotel, we travel around and enjoy. I think we spend quite a bit more than we would like to. The AI for us in Negril can be a little pricey, so we haven't been able to check them all out. What we do enjoy about AI is the fact that you will have many food options, and if you don't like what you put on your plate, there is more to choose from. You really shouldn't be disappointed with choosing AI or NI. Even when we do the AI, we still go out and enjoy and eat and drink elsewhere. Read reviews and look at the photos and see what might appeal to you.