Lol...JamaicaJeanne...I saw those posts.😏
Considering the Tahiti person didn't follow protocol, I'm surprised they let them in at all...and their post was very, very contradictory.

The person that asked the question directly to VisitJamaica.com...this is line that caused the "no" response....
"I asked if I can drive rental car to approved attractions / beaches / or anywhere else."
They cannot drive just "anywhere else" or to "approved attractions"...
but, you can still rent a vehicle and drive yourself around inside the resilient corridor as a category 2 tourist.

And, quite frankly...if anyone has truly been refused the chance to use a rental car...maybe they were deemed high risk in disobeying protocols and the Gov't/MOH made the choice to not allow them a vehicle rental. They have that option!