We stayed at Home Sweet Home and weren’t impressed but it was inexpensive. Not much of a pool. I’ve never stayed at Xtabi but remember researching them and only one had a kitchen and air conditioning. Plus it wasn’t appropriate for little ones so we didn’t stay there. Very nice restaurant and bar area though. Mostly we stayed at Catcha and got married there. Also enjoyed Villas sur Mer but it’s doesn’t have direct water access. My husband worked at Westender for many years and they have done many nice upgrades over the years but they are quite isolated. We’ve also stayed at Hide Awhile and Tensing Pen. We have a family house there but always preferred to stay in hotels before I could get my husband to the US. More privacy. Oh we loved Rock House also.