Having been to JA several times now, and returning again this year, I wish I had the guts to rent a car. Or even a scooter in Negril (even at my age I still ride a scooter for short trips around town, so I am an experienced rider). But I never have the guts to try. Just to help supplant the cost of getting to and from MBJ seems worthwhile to me, and since we stay on the Cliffs we could use the car to get back and forth from the beach. No guts, no glory I guess!