We did the Booby cay tour last December. It was ok, but nothing better. We were whisked to the island with very little banter with the captain or first mate. Option to explore the island which is small doesn’t take long. The lobster was good but not great. And then taken straight back to our resort. Just not the fun experience we had heard about and the average meal left us disappointed.
We had wante to do this trip for years but had it scuttled due to weather or bad timing on our parts. I think maybe if you have a bigger group it might be better.
We have also done the coffee river cruise and thoroughly enjoyed it, the vibe matched the tour and views and coffee was amazing.